Disappointed about your baby’s gender—and feeling bad about it? Dealing with gender disappointment during your pregnancy can be a hard. Here’s how to cope.
A girl. That was what I was hoping this pregnancy would reveal. I already had a boy and thought it’d be awesome for him to have a little sister. I wished so much that the sonogram would reveal that one of the twins would be a girl. And when they were both boys, I ended up dealing with gender disappointment I didn’t know I’d feel.
Gender disappointment isn’t as strange as you might think. I know so many people who really wanted one gender but got the other. Others who pursued crazy ways to conceive a preferred gender, and still others who’ve had to adjust to their new reality.
It’s common for people feel some gender disappointment to varying degrees. Unfortunately, we don’t always acknowledge our emotions, or we feel guilty about them.
We tell ourselves to get over it. That at least the baby is healthy, or that we shouldn’t complain when other people struggle to have even one child.
So when I learned I was carrying two boys (with no plans to have any more kids), I had to adjust my expectations.
Dealing with gender disappointment during your pregnancy
Dealing with gender disappointment is difficult, especially since a baby’s gender seems so petty compared to everything else. After all, we’d rather our babies are healthy, or that we can conceive at all, or carry to full term. Feeling disappointed about a baby’s gender doesn’t seem to warrant attention.
So we feel guilty about it, or bury it beneath, afraid to appear superficial. Except, like with any emotion, it’s healthier to accept and deal with it than push it away. If you can relate, don’t worry — dealing with gender disappointment is possible with honesty, time and the tips below:
Accept—don’t bury—your emotions
Perhaps the biggest pitfall with gender disappointment is denying the truth of your emotions. After all, people say, “So long as the baby is healthy,” implying that any other concern is trivial.
And while it may seem petty to fuss about a baby’s gender, we all have dreams of what our future with our kids will be. Long before you even had kids, you imagined yourself as a family. Or of holding your child in your arms—things that have yet to exist other than in your mind.
So when reality hits, you’re left dealing with a loss, not of a child but of the dreams you had.
Acknowledge your feelings for what they are. They’re emotions that happen to everyone and nothing to feel bad about. Talk to someone about how you had longed for a girl (or vice versa). Write your thoughts in a journal (this is my favorite one—affiliate link). Don’t keep the emotions buried inside, waiting to percolate later as resentment or frustration.
It’s okay to admit that you wanted another gender. No one’s going to see how you’re going to mess up your kids because they knew you wanted a boy when you instead got a girl.
When reality hits, you’re left dealing with a loss, not of a child but of the dreams you had.
Your child is an individual
We all have notions of what our kids will be like, based on their genders. And sometimes we assume they’ll fill their roles simply because they’re a boy or girl. You may have fantasized about dressing your little girl in cute clothes, or taking your little guy to sports games, both typical stereotypes of girls and boys.
But you may find that your child may not fit that gender role to begin with. Rather than trying to fit him into your interests and hobbies, be open to his own. Your little boy could care less about sports and would rather dive into art, and your little girl pulls off her frilly clothes and prefers t-shirts and sweat pants.
Besides, many of the interests you imagine doing with your child may not even rely on gender at all. Who says you can’t take your little girl to sports games, or dress your little guy in hip, stylish clothes?
We all meet our children for the first time, regardless of their sex. Your child being a boy doesn’t mean he’ll fulfill assumptions you may have had about raising boys, and vice versa for girls.
Instead leading with your images of who your child will be, treat him as an individual. You’ll appreciate his unique traits rather than what you assume he should be.
Consider the perks of your child’s gender
Once you’ve accepted the disappointment you feel about the turn of events, think about the many perks your child’s gender gives you.
It didn’t take me long to get over gender disappointment when I realized the benefits of hand-me-downs! I saved boxes of clothes and gear from my eldest, and was giddy when I realized how much we’d save from not having to buy too many items.
And since my twins were both boys, so much of what they have can be interchangeable, from clothes to toys.
Remind yourself that everything has pros and cons, including raising boys vs girls. You’ll see that having the opposite gender will turn out just as fine.
You’ll love your child no matter what
Every mom I’ve spoken with who felt any sense of gender disappointment, even those felt it throughout their whole pregnancy, admitted it all disappeared the minute they met their baby come delivery day.
Everything will turn out fine. You’re welcoming your new child into the world, regardless of his or her gender. As real and valid as your emotions are, rest assured they won’t plague you all through your child’s lifetime.
Because when you hold your baby in your arms, you will long forget how you even considered gender at all. Boy or girl, your child is yours, no matter what.
Want to cover all your bases during pregnancy? Get my FREE printable checklist and make sure you have everything taken care of before the baby is born. Download it below:
Tell me in the comments: What are your biggest surprises with gender disappointment?
Thank you for addressing this topic, as it’s one few people are willing to talk about! I think gender disappointment is pretty common, yet moms are worried about seeming ungrateful or unloving. That’s usually not the case at all! These are great tips for how to acknowledge and handle the emotions.
I think that’s the big problem with it, is that moms know they should be grateful and so think their feelings are valid. Like I tell my kids, ALL feelings are valid, we just have to learn how to deal with them (rather than hide them).
Funny timing on this post! I just had my baby girl two days ago! And when I first found out she was a girl, I was kind of upset.. I really wanted a boy! But now? I wouldn’t change this little angel for the WORLD!!! Great post my friend! <3 – http://www.domesticgeekgirl.com
First, CONGRATULATIONS!! Wow I’m so glad to hear the good news, Gingi! And yes, often the minute your little baby is born, you wouldn’t even imagine changing anything at all. Congrats again 🙂
Such an interesting topic. I have one of each so not a lot of disappointment but I really always wanted a daughter. Always. So when she was my first, I just thought.. “yes.”
With my son, I was so happy to have a boy for the next life journey.
But if we’re being honest.. if both had been boys, I KNOW I would have been disappointed and I feel awful saying that. I wouldn’t have at birth, but at the 20 week ultrasound.
I have a friend who has two boys and always wanted a daughter and is pregnant with one right now and I’m really happy for her because I know.. a third boy would have made her sad. Until she met him, of course!
We’re the same, except I wanted a boy first 🙂 So when I had my eldest, I was super excited. I know several moms who were disappointed when they heard news of the gender they were getting, but like you said, not at birth! And yeah I can see how you’d feel awful for feeling that feeling, but rest assured it’s normal and nothing to feel bad about! We all have our wishes 🙂
I didn’t find out any of my kids’ genders ahead of time. We had a girl and then a boy. I was convinced that the third was a girl and I was excited about the prospect of sisters. Alas, he was a boy. We’ve survived though, and I get the fun of brothers. I am still jealous of sisters though: I don’t have one and I don’t get to raise any.
My poor brother is the lone guy with four sisters (he’s right in the middle, too). I tend to believe that siblings get along more so because of various reasons (temperament, how much the parents prioritized sibling harmony, etc) than to gender itself. I’ve seen some great brother-sister relationships as well.
My first child is a girl, and I knew there were pros and cons to have either gender as a second child. I wanted a boy too, but I also wanted my daughter to have a sister like I do. When I found out I was having a boy, I shared my feelings with a friend who has a brother. She is very close to him, and it made me realize that my kids can have a good relationship regardless of their genders. Now I can’t imagine my family any other way!
I totally agree that gender doesn’t always define sibling relationships as much as, say, parents prioritizing how well their kids get along or even their temperaments.
No gender disappointments here, but it was nice to have both a boy and a girl(s). I think it is wonderful that you are talking about this.
Thanks! I think many people have varying degrees of disappointment about their kids’ genders, some are quicker to pass than others. It definitely helps to accept it right away!
Thank you for posting about this! There can be such a sense of guilt with gender disappointment. I always thought I’d have to have three kids just to have a girl. Obviously we were in for the opposite of my expectations. The Husband didn’t care that our second was a girl; but I have to admit I was a little let down. Who knows what this next one will be. The Husband and I both admit now that we’d love to have a boy (we’ve been warned that we shouldn’t have more than 3), but reality is that you’ll love that child no matter what gender it is.
Haha with my own three boys (I wanted boys), I thought I too would have to have a zillion kids to have that one boy. Well, that’s the exact opposite of what happened! I’m excited to find out what #3 will be for you too Leslie!
I really love having a boy and a girl. I think it’s important to tell people it’s okay to experience gender disappointment. These are great tips.
I wonder if gender disappointment is more common with people who have multiple children of all the same gender.
Thanks, Melissa. I would imagine it’s more common for families with same-gendered kids, especially if there’s a lot of them. Although I have heard of parents who have mixed gender kids and still disappointed because they wanted, say, a sister bond between their daughters (but got a boy and girl instead).
Thank you so much for this post! I just found out today at the ultrasound that we are having our third boy and I couldn’t help bit be in shock. Every wives tale that I came across said it was a girl…even the great ring test. I held it together for the appointment but lost it in the car with my husband. He is super excited but I was just SO sure it a a girl! When I finally looked at your posting its was like I was reading from my own thoughts! Thank you so much for normalizing these feelings….i think now I am just anticipating the words from other people like “maybe next time! Or “oh shoot!”. I almost don’t want to tell anyone just because of those reactions! As the day progresses I am more at peace with it and know that I was just meant to have crazy boys!
You bring up a good point—people’s comments! Not only do you have to deal with your own disappointment, but now must brace yourself for the inevitable comments and questions people say or even ‘joke’ about. I had so many of those as well, even now, with the “Are you going to try for a girl?” (As if there was ever even a guarantee lol). I take in jest as well, but I always think that comments like that are unnecessary.
First of all I am really ashamed to be writing this post, as i thought i would never be “those” people and always thought of my self as a grateful person. I am 37 with my first baby. I am 4 months and had two scary incidents where I had a gush of blood. yesterday I received the results of my genetic testing. baby is fine. no abnormalities, thank God. I also found out I am having a little baby girl. i have been nonstop crying since yesterday. i was bent on having a boy. all the old wives tale indicated i was having a boy. i dreamed up this imaginary world where i had a boy and how i would raise him and break the news to my friends and family. the thought of a girl never occured in my mind for a split second. i would refer to my earlier ultra sounds as “he”. everything was he when i spoke about the baby. i prayed on having a boy too. my husband wanted a boy my mom wanted a boy and im sure my husband moms wanted a boy but she said she was happy either way. my husband thinks maybe there still could be a slight chance it could be a boy. the results are 98%. but he’s being real supportive. he does express his want for a boy but in the end says as long as the baby is healthy and i am being ungrateful. which i totally am. all around me there are people who are having issues with conceiving or they have to take meds. i am really shocked at myself for feeling this way. i dont want people to think i am a bad person. i honestly wish i wouldnt feel this way and just embrace what i have been given. even though i know now, i am still in shock and denial. whats wrong with me? i am a girl. im so sad and depressed.
Hi Sarah,
It takes a lot to admit something that to some folks would seem petty, so no shame here! I don’t think feeling disappointed in a baby’s gender is necessarily tied to gratitude. We know we’re blessed, we know we have it so much better than many people, so I don’t think you or anyone else is being ungrateful or a ‘bad’ person at all.
What I think happens with gender disappointment is that we’re grieving over a dream we once had. Like you said, you had spent considerable time thinking of life with a boy, you identified your growing baby as a ‘he,’ and everyone assumed or wished you had a boy. So to suddenly go from that to realizing all this time it’s going to be a girl is a bit of a shock.
It’s not that you’re ungrateful, it’s that you now have to reconcile your past dreams or notions with what is real and going to happen. It takes some time. I remember when I found out both my twins were boys, and I already had an eldest. Before then, I imagined one was a boy and the other a girl, and I actually had day dreams of my kids, from infancy through when they’d be adults, and I imagined two boys and a girl. So it took a while to match up those dreams, sort of change them, to accommodate reality.
And since you just found out yesterday, I would think it would take some time to adjust. Try not to get too down on yourself or feel guilty. We can’t help our emotions, after all. They come and go, and we can’t be made to feel guilty for having them. Acknowledge how you feel, don’t try to hide it, but do be proactive about what you can do to accept this new circumstance.
The best part is that everyone I know who has felt this way has adjusted. You will love your baby girl tremendously you’ll almost be in disbelief about this period you’re having right now. Everything will turn out all right, even if you can’t see it just yet.
I know I have a had a hard time dealing with this myself but it is a little bit different. I was told for over 5 months that I was having a little girl. After a complicated delivery I was told I had a little boy. I wouldn’t change anything because I love him but it has been a very big adjustment.
Wow what a roller coaster of emotions, Kait! I know someone else who had that happen to her, too. She was told she was going to have a boy—even had a boy’s name picked out, boy’s clothes, all that. But come delivery day, she got a girl. It’s definitely an adjustment!
I wish I would have found this sooner! I have already come to terms with my baby boy but I was so disappointed at first. I did a gender reveal and my fiance knew but I didn’t. I wish I wouldn’t have done it but this is my first and might be my only so I wanted to make sure I didn’t miss out on a pregnancy event. I had always dreamed of a little girl. My mom had me and my sister and my family is saturated with girls so I thought I was definitely going to have a girl, I wanted a little mini me. My fiance has 2 boys and a girl from a previous marriage so I was hoping we’d have a girl so that we would have 2 of each. I did have other moms who went through the same thing and they reassured me that boys are much easier and love their moms a ton. I’m still excited because hes mine and feeling him move in my belly helps strengthen my love for him.
I’m glad to hear you’ve come to terms with it, Kala! We all have dreams of our kids, long before we meet them, so it’s only natural for you to feel grief over losing that dream. The good news is, you’ll have such a strong bond with your little guy! As a mom of three boys, I can’t imagine it any other way.
My husband’s family is a girl and then 4 boys. My family is my brother and then myself. While I didn’t really care what we were pregnant with–seriously, “goat” was on my apathetic list of options–I saw the advantage in having a boy first. My husband really wanted a daughter first. All of the old wives’ tales and two midwives said it was going to be a boy. However, my husband decided to pay for the fancy ultrasound a few days ago to “find out for sure.” We were told we’re having a girl. Despite being what he wanted, he’s not super-excited…probably because he had resigned himself to the idea that we were having a boy. I told him he can just wait and find out when it’s born like I had been planning on doing anyway. 😉 (I didn’t want a ton of gender-specific clothing anyway which is why I planned on waiting to find out, but I went along with the ultrasound because I know he feels a little left out of the whole process.)
Ha! Funny how our moods can change once we convince ourselves of the other idea. I tended to buy gender-neutral stuff too, not just because of the gender issue but in case we wanted more kids, those would be easier to hand down 🙂
Reading this makes me feel so much better! I’m FINALLY getting over my gender disappointment for this pregnancy (this is baby #2). I have a 3 year old daughter, and the husband and I were really hoping for a boy this time. I’ve always wanted one of each and when we found out we were having another girl, I cried almost non stop for the first few days and felt really down about it for quite awhile after. It wasn’t until going through my daughter’s old clothes that I got excited about another girl. There were so many cute outfits that she never wore or only wore once or twice, and I’m excited to put them on this baby. I’m so glad to see this topic discussed in a positive light, as I got many negative comments about how I was ungrateful and so many jokes that I didn’t find remotely amusing. Thank you for this.
Absolutely, Alyssa! So glad the article resonated and made you feel better. You’re not alone, or any worse than another mom. It’s a natural feeling we all get when we grieve not for a baby but for a lost dream. And yes, with time it gets so much better!